Fox Hollow Farm Part 1: The Murders

When authorities found thousands of human bones scattered in the woods of Fox Hollow Farm in the 90s, all arrows started to point at one potential culprit of the plethora of missing and murdered gay men in the Indianapolis area.

Show Notes

Herb Baumeister seemed to be the normal dude with a family, living in a relatively normal residential neighborhood of Indianapolis. No one knew how dangerous he really was, or the capabilities he had to live a double life and hide it from his family. In this episode, we explore the murders along a highway between Indiana and Ohio, and piece together the clues left behind by Herb Baumeister at Fox Hollow Farm. Stay tuned for the residual and potentially ghostly remains of Fox Hollow Farm next week in Part 2: The Hauntings.


Estep, R. and Robert Graves (2019), “The Horrors of Fox Hollow Farm: Unraveling the History and Hauntings of a Serial Killer’s Home,” Llewellyn Publications.

Weinstein, F. and Melinda Wilson (1998), “Where The Bodies Are Buried,” St. Martin’s Press.

Contreras, Natalia (May 16, 2019), “A Serial Killer Buried Bodies on His Westfield Property. Now Some of the Land Is For Sale,”, retrieved from:

Geringer, Joseph (Dec. 13, 2007), “The Dark Side,” Crime Library, CourtTV, originally at, retrieved from:

Albert, Natasha et al. (Fall 2005), “Herb Baumeister: The I-70 Strangler,” Radford University, Research Paper, retrieved from:,%20Herb%20-%20fall,%202005.pdf

Connect With Us

IG: @ghoulishtendenciespodcast

FB: @ghoulishtendenciespodcast

Twitter: @ghoulishpodcast


Researched, Written, Edited & Produced by Gabi Fiore

Music by Dan Moretti