amityville part one: the defeo murders

Amityville Part One: The DeFeo Murders

Before the Lutz’s moved into the house at 112 Ocean Avenue, the home belonged to the DeFeo family. This is the true Amityville Horror.

Show Notes

On November 12th, 1974, six members of the DeFeo family were brutally murdered in their beds. The eldest son, Butch DeFeo the lone survivor. Was it Butch who brutally shot his entire family? Was someone else involved? Or did the voices of the house make him do it?


Lowe, Ed (Nov. 15, 1998), “The horrors in Amityville: Six murders on Ocean Avenue become a media circus rippling around the world,” Newsday, Retrieved from:

No author (Feb. 27, 2012), “New Evidence Raises Questions In Decades-Old Amityville Horror Murders,” WLNY Channel 2 (Television), Retrieved from:

Schemo, Diana (June 25, 1992), “‘Amityville’ Prisoner Says Movie Money Tainted Defense,” New York Times.

Vecsey, George (Nov. 15, 1974), “Neighbors Recall DeFeos As ‘Nice, Normal Family’: ‘Drink and Play Music’,” New York Times.

No author (retrieval date: April 6, 2020), “The Murders,” The Amityville Files, Retrieved from:

Sullivan, Gerard and Harvey Aronson (Jan. 1, 1981), “High Hopes: The Amityville Murders,” Coward McCann.

Proud, Geoffrey (Producer) (June 9, 2002), “Horror in Amityville,” A&E TV Network.

No author (last edited: April 5, 2020), “Amityville, New York,” Wikipedia, Retrieved from:,_New_York

Kennedy, Michael (Nov. 29, 2019), “How The Amityville Horror Ended Up With 22 Sequels,” Screen Rant, Retrieved from:

No author (retrieved date: April 6, 2020), “Ronald DeFeo,” Murderpedia, Retrieved from:

Berry-Dee, Christopher (May 1, 2003), “Talking with Serial Killers: The Most Evil People in the World Tell Their Own Stories,” John Blake New Ed Edition.

IG: @ghoulishtendenciespodcast

FB: @ghoulishtendenciespodcast

Twitter: @ghoulishpodcast


Researched & written by Kim Douthit 

Edited & produced by Gabi Fiore

Music by Dan Moretti